HW#7, WP#2 rough draft
Summer Bretz
English 102
Section # 24271
10/17/2009
Rough Draft
Should a Pregnancy be Termed “High Risk” Based on a Maternal Age of Over 30?
Research shows that women in their 30’s are more likely to have complications with their pregnancy, delivery, and with their newborns. Many women are waiting until later in life to start their families, but is this trend a high risk for our children and these mothers? Some opinions show that starting a family later in life is beneficial. These moms are generally more stable in all areas of life. Giving their children more patients, stability, and financial benefits. Yet, other opinions are that it is too high of a risk for babies and mothers. Older moms have a higher rate of complications with delivery resulting in cesarean sections instead of natural deliveries. Their babies are also more likely to have chromosomal disorders. Doctors have done several studies on how age affects these outcomes and how to give special care to expectant mothers over the age of 30.
My first source comes from an article titled A Woman’s Age and High Risk Pregnancy, found on babymed.com. This article sates “There is no precise age beyond which a woman becomes more susceptible to pregnancy complications.” The purpose of this article is too help expectant older moms to understand the potential risks and complications that may result in pregnancy due to advanced maternal age; however, says that there is no exact age that distinguishes the title of advanced maternal age. The author of this article is anonymous, but the web site it is found on is used as a medical reference tool for expectant mothers. This article is was found via the internet and was posted in 2005, so there may be more current information. Even though this source is in favor of older mothers conceiving it does not leave out the facts. “A woman under 30 has a miscarriage risk of about 10%, while woman over 20 has a 55% miscarriage risk. The increase in the mother’s age increased the risk for fetal malformations and other chromosomal anomalies such as down syndrome.” (A Woman’s Age and High Risk pregnancy). I think this source is a good middle ground for my paper. It gives good view points to both sides of the spectrum.
A Woman’s Age and High Risk Pregnancy. Retrieved September 16, 2009, from http://babymed.com/Blog/Blog.aspx?9
Another article related to this topic is Advanced maternal Age - What’s in a name? was found through a women speak blog, but was original posted through the MUSC health. The author is anonymous, but there are statistics from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists within the article. This source also has a positive outlook for older mothers stating that the label of advanced maternal age is outdated and was originally termed because 30 was the age that doctors offered amniocentesis, which is no longer the case. This source states that age related complications do not apply until women are in their 40’s. This author does leave out what those complications may be or any exact statistics. This article was posted this year and is very current, but lacks as much credibility as the others may have.
( 2009 February 16). Advanced Maternal Age - What’s in a name? Retrieved September 16, 2009, from http://blogs.musc.edu/womenspeak/post/2009/02/advanced-maternal-age-
Advanced maternal Age- the Mature Gravida is another source found online. This source is a three year study of women 35 years and older. This is another article that would be on the pro side of the argument for older mothers. It shows that the differences between delivering mother’s in their 20’s and 30’s were insignificant. This source is very different than any others in my research. This research is from 1985, but even though it is older I feel that it is still significant to my research question. It helps to make my topic more well rounded by giving another perspective.
Kirz, DS., Dorchester W., Freeman RK. (1985 May 1). Advanced Maternal Age: the mature gravida. PubMed. Retrieved October 2, 2009, from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3993714
My next source is an article titled Cancer Risk and Advanced maternal Age. This was the only study I found that approached advanced maternal age from this angle. The author does not give her credentials, but does that she is an “older mommy”. I thought this was very interesting research and it is very new. This article was published in August of 2009. This source is relevant because it brings up a whole new risk for older mothers to worry about before deciding to start their family. This research states “The likelihood of children under 15 having one of the most common forms of childhood cancer (Leukemia, lymphoma, central nervous system tumor, neuroblastoma, Wilms’ tumor, bone cancer, and soft tissue sarcoma) is 1 in 435. The odds, however, seem to be higher in children of older mommies.” This source does leave out any of the other risks or complications due to advanced maternal age. This article focuses specifically to the links between cancer in children under 15 and advanced maternal age.
Raquel. (2009, August 5). Cacer Risk and Advanced Maternal Age. Battling For Health. Retrieved September 26, 2009, from http://battlingforhealth.com/2009/08/cancer-risk-and-advanced-maternal-age/
The next resource I have was found through The American College of Obstetricians and gynecologists. The title is Causes of Fetal Death in Women of Advanced Maternal Age. This source relates the negative side of waiting until your 30’s to start having children. It states “From 1978 to 1995, older women were at a statistically significant increased risk for “unexplained” fetal death.” There are two authors, both of which are MD’s. The intended audience is other doctors or researchers. This resource is very detailed and contains many useful statistics. This article was published in 1997 and I believe it is still accurate and up to date.
Fretts, Ruth C. MD,. Usher, Robert H. MD. (1997). Causes of Fetal Death in Women of Advanced Maternal Age. Obstetrics & Gynecology, 89(1). Retrieved October 13, 2009, from http://journals.lww.com/greenjournal/abstract/1997/
Pregnancy Over Age 30 is an article found online through MUSC children’s hospital. This article is anonymous and gives several facts regarding chromosomal abnormalities, and a few on risks of miscarriage and maternal age. This source focuses on chromosome abnormalities such as down syndrome. There is no date given for publication. This article is still useful for my research because it is the best source found specifically focusing on chromosomal abnormalities, which is a huge concern for mothers and doctors in regards to advanced maternal age.
Pregnancy Over age 30. MUSC Children’s Hospital. Retrieved September 16, 2009, from http://www.musckids.com/health_library/hrprgnant/over30/htm
Pregnancy Late in Life: A Hospital-Based Study of Birth Outcomes is an article from the Journal of Women’s Health. This source was written by four Ph.D.’s., it was written in 2008. This research is current and provides a lot of statistics regarding the outcomes of deliveries from women 30 and older regarding low birth weight and preterm deliveries. The format that this article is written in, is a scientific report. This source provides many graphs and charts to make the information easy for the reader to understand. The audience intended for this article would be doctor and other scientists. This source is credible and I think it is one of the best sources that I can use for my article.
Delpisheh, A., Brabin, L., Attia, E., Brabin B. (2008). Pregnancy Late in Life: A hospital-Based Study of Birth Outcomes. Journal of Women’s Health, 17(6), 965-970. Retrieved September 2009, from Academic Premier database.
The final source used for my research is my anatomy text book, Principles of Anatomy and Physiology. This source has two authors and is very reputable. This textbook gives facts regarding down syndrome, which is one of the risk for babies born to mothers that are older. It states “ Older women are more likely to have a down syndrome baby. The chance of having a baby with this syndrome, which is less than one in 3,000 for women under age 30, increases to one in 300 in the 35-39 age group and to one in nine ate age 48.” (1169). This textbook is the 12th edition and the newest one, it was published in 2009. This section is specifically about down syndrome, but the risks of this chromosomal disorder in regards to advanced maternal age is so significant that there is a section highlighted for this purpose.
Tortora, Gerard., Derrickson, Bryan. (2009). Principles of Anatomy and Physiology, 12th Edition. Disorders: Homeostatic Imbalances (pp. 1169). New York: Wiley.
I believe my research is well organized and well rounded. I have three articles that are supportive of older mothers. I also have two that give both sides of the story. I have 3 that give pretty harsh research about serious complications that mothers are putting themselves and their babies at risk for. The accumulative research shows that the age for “advanced maternal age” has gone up to 35 instead of 30 years-old. I think that I have enough research to provide a good paper and sufficient answers to my research question.